Lake Geneva, WI, is not just a picturesque getaway with stunning lake views, charming boutiques, and luxury real estate—it’s also a haven for food lovers. Whether you’re craving a fine dining experience, a cozy café, or a laid-back lakeside meal, Lake Geneva has something for everyone.
As the #1 real estate agent in Lake Geneva, Holly Collins knows more than just homes—she also knows where to find the best eats in town. Whether you’re moving to the area, looking for a weekend retreat, or just visiting, Holly can guide you to the best restaurants in town.
Lake Geneva WI Real Estate and Homes For Sale
1. The Grandview Restaurant at The Geneva Inn
📍 Location: N2009 S. Lake Shore Drive
⭐ Best For: Fine dining with a lakeside view
If you’re looking for a romantic lakeside dining experience, The Grandview Restaurant is a must-visit. Overlooking the stunning waters of Lake Geneva, this upscale spot is perfect for date nights, anniversaries, or anyone looking for an elegant dining experience with breathtaking views.
What to Order:
- Lobster Bisque – Rich, creamy, and filled with fresh lobster meat
- Filet Mignon – Cooked to perfection and served with seasonal vegetables
- Crème Brûlée – A delightful dessert with the perfect caramelized top
💡 Holly’s Real Estate Tip: Love the lakefront views? Lake Geneva has stunning waterfront homes that offer similar scenery every day. If you’re dreaming of waking up to lake views, Holly Collins can help you find your perfect home.
2. Oakfire
📍 Location: 831 Wrigley Drive
⭐ Best For: Wood-fired Neapolitan pizza
For a casual but high-quality dining experience, Oakfire is a local favorite. This Italian-inspired eatery is known for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, made fresh in wood-fired ovens. Pair your pizza with a local craft beer or a glass of wine while enjoying the lakeside ambiance.
What to Order:
- Margherita Pizza – Classic flavors with fresh mozzarella, basil, and San Marzano tomatoes
- Truffle Mushroom Pizza – Rich, earthy, and absolutely delicious
- Arancini – Crispy risotto balls stuffed with cheese
💡 Holly’s Real Estate Tip: If you love the bustling yet relaxed vibe of downtown Lake Geneva, Holly can help you find a home within walking distance of these top restaurants.
3. Mars Resort
📍 Location: W4098 South Shore Drive
⭐ Best For: Classic Wisconsin supper club experience
A visit to Lake Geneva isn’t complete without experiencing a classic Wisconsin supper club, and Mars Resort is one of the best. With a retro, nostalgic feel and stunning lake views, this spot is perfect for a relaxed evening with family and friends.
What to Order:
- Friday Fish Fry – A Wisconsin tradition with crispy beer-battered cod
- Prime Rib – A house specialty, slow-cooked to juicy perfection
- Old Fashioned Cocktail – A Wisconsin supper club staple
💡 Holly’s Real Estate Tip: Want to be close to all the action? Holly Collins can help you find a lakefront or vacation home near these iconic restaurants.
4. Café Calamari
📍 Location: 10 E. Geneva Street, Williams Bay
⭐ Best For: Upscale Italian cuisine
Located just a short drive from downtown Lake Geneva, Café Calamari is a gem for Italian food lovers. Whether you’re craving a hearty pasta dish or fresh seafood, this restaurant delivers a high-end yet welcoming atmosphere.
What to Order:
- Calamari Fritti – Lightly fried and served with house-made marinara
- Lobster Ravioli – House-made pasta stuffed with fresh lobster
- Veal Saltimbocca – A classic Italian dish with prosciutto and sage
💡 Holly’s Real Estate Tip: If you love the charm of Williams Bay, Holly can show you beautiful properties in this quaint but lively area.
5. Egg Harbor Café
📍 Location: 827 Main Street
⭐ Best For: Breakfast and brunch
For a fantastic breakfast or brunch, Egg Harbor Café is a local favorite. This family-friendly café offers a diverse menu, from healthy omelets to indulgent pancakes, making it a great stop before heading out to explore Lake Geneva.
What to Order:
- Georgia Grits & Eggs – A Southern-inspired favorite with stone-ground grits
- Chocolate Chip Pancakes – Perfect for those with a sweet tooth
- Habanero Hash & Eggs – A spicy twist on a breakfast classic
💡 Holly’s Real Estate Tip: Want to start your mornings with great coffee and brunch spots nearby? Holly Collins knows the best neighborhoods within walking distance of downtown cafes.
6. Popeye’s on Lake Geneva
📍 Location: 811 Wrigley Drive
⭐ Best For: Casual dining with lake views
Popeye’s is an iconic restaurant in Lake Geneva, not to be confused with the fast-food chain! This beloved local spot offers a mix of American classics, fresh seafood, and BBQ. Its outdoor seating provides fantastic lake views, making it a popular stop for both tourists and locals.
What to Order:
- Rotisserie Chicken – Their house specialty, slow-cooked to perfection
- Seafood Platter – A mix of shrimp, crab cakes, and fresh fish
- Wisconsin Cheese Curds – A must-try classic
💡 Holly’s Real Estate Tip: Love being near the water? Holly Collins can find you a condo or lake house just steps from downtown Lake Geneva.
7. Next Door Pub & Pizzeria
📍 Location: 411 Interchange North
⭐ Best For: Local pub atmosphere and great pizza
If you’re in the mood for a cozy pub experience with fantastic pizza, Next Door Pub is a top pick. This family-friendly restaurant has been a Lake Geneva staple for years and is known for great service, delicious food, and a welcoming atmosphere.
What to Order:
- The Pub’s Famous Garlic Breadsticks – Served with homemade marinara
- Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza – A creative and indulgent twist on two classics
- Wisconsin Craft Beer – Pair your meal with a locally brewed pint
💡 Holly’s Real Estate Tip: Looking for a neighborhood with a strong sense of community? Holly can find the perfect home near friendly local spots like Next Door Pub.
Final Thoughts: Food and Real Estate in Lake Geneva
Lake Geneva, WI, is not only a premier real estate destination but also a food lover’s paradise. Whether you’re moving to Lake Geneva, buying a vacation home, or just visiting, there’s no shortage of incredible restaurants to explore.
And when it comes to finding your dream home in Lake Geneva, no one knows the area better than Holly Collins. As the #1 real estate agent in Lake Geneva, WI, Holly is your go-to expert for buying, selling, or investing in local real estate.
Looking for lakefront property, a charming downtown condo, or a luxury retreat? Contact Holly Collins today and start your journey toward living the Lake Geneva lifestyle—with the best restaurants just minutes away!
Holly Collins
Holly.Collins@compass.com
773-294-9308
